Schrödinger's goldfish.......and wild geese.
I have two goldfish who's job it is to look after my water storage pond and prevent mosquito's breeding in it. But in the winter I move them into a pallet cube of about 200L that is insulated and has a small pond heater in it.
The last one I bought was 300W so I stepped down to a 200W one to make things cheaper, but during this recent freeze it froze over and appeared to have stopped working.
I bought the stainless steel one because I don't like looking at a 240v heating element in water with just a thin glass envelope preventing electrocution. So I brought it in and tested for resistance and - nothing. Fuse was ok. I plugged it into a wattmeter and it showed 0 Watts.
So I set to taking it apart and was surprisingly easy, only held in with a dab of silicone inside of a cast silicone plug.
Checked every component and all seemed good, apart from the Thyristor which I couldn't test. As I'd stretched the heating element a bit I had to rewind that, and put it back together again. Testing it in the sink - it worked !
I suspected that it was a bad connection with the heating element that I had disturbed, so put it back in the tank again.
Went inside and checked the wattmeter, and it showed 200W - which was correct.
Checked again in 5 minutes and - 0 Watts.
So I pull it out again, bring it in, pull it apart and try testing the element. I bridged the thyristor and it got hot as it should. So put it back together again and test it in the sink - and it gets hot.
At this point I thought, rather than risk dead goldfish by freezing, I could bridge the thyristor so the heating element is on all the time, so at least it would heat the water - but may get too hot - boiled goldfish. So to prevent that I could use a timeswitch to turn it on and off every hour or so.
- But that is a lot of programming on an electronic one............but it does have a random feature for security.
But what is random on a timeswitch?
is it on for an hour and off for an hour, or on for 3 hours or 7 then off for 4 ?
If I used that feature connected to the pond heater, I cannot see the fish, or know the temperature until I look, at which point the fish are either dead or alive - so I now have Schrödinger's goldfish !!
I decided against that, and put it out again - same thing - works, then doesn't.
In again - test again - works fine !!!!!
Out again, doesn't !! FFS !
Tried plugging it directly into the wattmeter and ....... 0 Watts - but it is getting hot ???
Ok - faulty wattmeter. So I plugged an inspection light in and - it reads 150W no problem.
The only thing I can think of is this pond heater only had one diode in it filtering the supply to the op-amp, and as that controls the switching of the thyristor - is it only switching on for a half cycle, and the negative cycle of the AC? This may well confuse the watt meter enough to show 0 Watts.
So it looks like it was working after all, and the 200w heater is not up to keeping the top frost free. But at least it is preventing it freezing solid.
Back to the 300W one when I can find it.
Insides.....
View attachment 517991
3 resistors top right step down from 230v and the diode under them provides supply limited by a zener I presume then into the bulk cap. The chip is an LM358 opamp using a zener as a reference and the variable pot at the end will be adjusting the trip point for a temperature sensor under the silicone bung. The big thyristor at the top does the switching straight to the element in the ceramic holder - which is rather nice. Black plug is a plug with two connectors that two prongs of the PCB fit into, with crimps onto the heater coils.